
Most observers of Baptist life know by
now that a judge ruled in favor of Southwestern Baptist
Theological Seminary and its president Paige Patterson in a case
filed by Sheri Klouda. (If not, the story is on page 13.)
The former Hebrew
professor claimed gender discrimination and breach of contract
when Patterson denied her tenure.
The judge said the
religious liberty guarantees in the First Amendment allow for
churches and church-owned institutions to make religiously
motivated decisions about employment.
I think the judge
was right. Religious freedom gives churches and individuals the
right to be wrong.
Only a hard-core
fundamentalist like Patterson and his dwindling flock of followers
would see the dismissal and mistreatment of Dr. Klouda as a good
thing. By all accounts, she was a superb Hebrew language professor
with conservative credentials (a graduate of Criswell College and
Southwestern Seminary) and a cooperative spirit.
Never mind that
she is not ordained, is not a pastor and has affirmed the
theologically narrow 2000 Baptist Faith and Message
statement. Forget that Klouda was hired in 2002, the year before
Patterson became president, and did nothing other than serve as a
competent and well-liked professor until denied tenure in 2004.
Was Patterson
wrong? Many of us think so. But the judge has ruled that — in
religious settings — individuals and institutions have the right
to be wrong.
While I regret
that Dr. Klouda and her family have suffered through this harsh
treatment, my sympathy for those caught in the snares of
fundamentalism is running low. Since taking control of the
Southern Baptist Convention more than two and a half decades ago,
male-dominated fundamentalist leadership has consistently adopted
theological positions and enforced institutional policies that
relegate women to secondary status.
Klouda’s dismissal
is just another stomp along this well-worn path. It is consistent
with the kind of religious fundamentalism exhibited by Patterson
his whole life — and repeatedly affirmed by the majority vote of
Southern Baptists since 1979.
As one friend said
to me: “Southern Baptists got what they asked for — and probably
what they deserved.”
And as another
friend often reminds me: “If you pick up a snake, don't complain
when it bites you.”
The judge has made
it clear: Religious leaders have the right and freedom to
discriminate against women and to mistreat employees based on
gender or other reasons shaped by their theology.
So let me also
make this clear: Fundamentalists do that consistently.
“If you pick up
that snake …?”